Language Learning Apps vs. Traditional Methods: What Works Best for Kids?

Now that we have identified pitfalls for all ages and key milestones for younger learners, KaiBan wants to be sure to share some insight for our more technically included learners.

In an increasingly digital world, parents are presented with a multitude of options for teaching their children anything–let alone a new language. From engaging apps to traditional methods like classroom instruction and books, the choices can be overwhelming. KaiBan explores the pros and cons of language learning apps compared to traditional methods, in order to help the KaiBan Community determine what works best for your child.

Language learning apps have surged in popularity in recent years, driven by advancements in technology and the growing demand for accessible education. With interactive features and gamified learning experiences, these apps appeal to children’s natural curiosity and playfulness.

KaiBan lists some of the most well-known language learning apps and what each app is best known for in order for our KaiBan Community members to identify which one can help supplement their in-home language learning efforts.

• Duolingo: This app offers bite-sized lessons and gamified learning experiences. This is best for independent exercise time–particularly for older learners (likely in their tweens or teens).
• Rosetta Stone: This app focuses on immersive learning through context and visual cues. This app caters to learners of all ages, so it is a tool we recommend for the duration of your at-home lessons.
• Babbel: This app provides conversation-focused lessons tailored to real-life situations. Babbel is a strong tool for all ages, but there are some age restrictions for specific offerings:
  • Babbel Live classes- Learners ages 16 or older can book and attend Babbel Live classes.
  • Babbel Professional for Education- available for students age of 13+.
• Memrise: This app, tailored for users ages 12+, uses spaced repetition and mnemonic devices to enhance vocabulary retention. It uses interactive exercises and video clips of native speakers to improve pronunciation.

As a language-learning platform, KaiBan encourages a multi-layered approach to learning a new language, as this approach reinforces language acquisition in various aspects of life. However, some tactics may work better than others based on each individual. As such, we want to outline a few key benefits of language learning apps.

1. Accessibility and Convenience: Language learning apps can be accessed on smartphones and tablets, allowing children to learn anytime, anywhere. This flexibility makes it easy to fit learning into busy schedules.
2. Engaging and Interactive: Many apps use gamification techniques, such as points, levels, and rewards, to motivate children. This interactive format keeps kids engaged and makes learning feel less like a chore. Additionally, for parents new to teaching or struggling with creativity, apps make the process clearer and easier.
3. Personalized Learning: Apps often adapt to the learner’s pace and level, providing personalized exercises based on their progress. This individualized approach can cater to different learning styles and preferences.
4. Multimedia Resources: Language learning apps incorporate audio, visuals, and interactive exercises, catering to various learning styles. This multimedia approach can enhance understanding and retention.
5. Instant Feedback: Many apps offer real-time feedback, allowing your little learner to understand their mistakes and learn from them immediately. This instant reinforcement can boost confidence and encourage further practice.

While KaiBan is a huge supporter of digital language learner resources, there are some aspects we encourage parents to pay close attention to while testing teaching tactics. Below are 4 key things to consider:

1. Screen Time Concerns: Increased use of screens raises concerns about the amount of time children spend on devices. Balancing screen time with other activities is crucial for overall well-being and general learning adaptability.
2. Limited Interaction: While apps can provide foundational vocabulary and grammar, they often lack the conversational practice that comes from real-life interactions. This can hinder the development of speaking and listening skills. Be sure to practice conversation with your little learner to offset any digital learning drawbacks.
3. Lack of Structure: Some children may thrive on structured learning environments, which ssome apps may not provide. Without clear goals and schedules, learning can become inconsistent. Consider incorporating apps during independent practice time and give this portion of the lesson a finite amount of time in order to incorporate structure in your at-home lessons.
4. Potential for Distraction: Tablets and smartphones can be distracting, with notifications and other apps vying for attention. Maintaining focus on language learning can be a challenge. Be sure to implement practices to limit distractions so that your child doesn’t veer from their designated learning time.

Traditional language learning methods include at-home instruction, private tutoring, language immersion, and using various books. These methods have been proven effective over many years and have their own set of advantages.

1. 1. Structured Learning Environment: Traditional methods often provide a clear curriculum and structured lessons, allowing children to progress systematically. This can be beneficial for learners who thrive on routine.
   2. Interactive Communication: Face-to-face interaction with parents and peers fosters essential communication skills. Children learn to engage in conversations, respond to questions, and practice pronunciation in real time.
   3. Cultural Context: Traditional methods often incorporate cultural elements, helping children understand the nuances of language use in different contexts. This cultural immersion enriches their learning experience.
   4. Supervision and Support: Parents and tutors can offer immediate assistance, answer questions, and provide tailored feedback, ensuring children grasp complex concepts effectively.
   5. Social Interaction: Learning in a group or personal setting encourages collaboration and social interaction, allowing children to practice language skills in a supportive environment.

1. Time and Accessibility: Traditional efforts and private tutoring can be expensive not only on the wallet but also on your time at home following school and work. You or your child may not be mentally open to additional effort following a 6-8-hour work or school day. This can limit interest for some families.
2. Pace Variability: In an in-person setting, parents with multiples may find that their children may progress at different speeds. Some siblings may struggle to keep up with others, while stronger learners may find paces adjusted to younger siblings too slow, potentially leading to frustration or disinterest.
3. Limited Flexibility: Traditional methods often require specific time commitments and may not accommodate busy family schedules. This can be a barrier for some families.
4. Potential for Burnout: The structured nature of traditional learning can sometimes lead to boredom or burnout, especially if children feel pressured to perform. Remain mindful of this as burnout does not only impact the “student” but also the “parent instructor.”

Use language learning apps as a supplemental tool. Incorporate short app sessions into your child’s daily routine, such as during breakfast or before bed. This can enhance learning without overwhelming them.

Pair app-based learning with opportunities for real-life conversations. Encourage your child to practice speaking with family members, friends, or language partners, fostering practical use of their skills.

Combine app learning with traditional resources like books, videos, and music. This varied exposure can enhance vocabulary and comprehension while keeping learning dynamic and enjoyable.

Establish a designated learning space where your child feels comfortable practicing their language skills. This supportive environment can encourage regular practice and exploration.

Supplement language learning with cultural experiences. Cook traditional meals, attend cultural events, or explore the art and music of the language’s country to deepen understanding and appreciation.

When it comes to teaching children a new language, both language learning apps and traditional methods have unique strengths and weaknesses. While apps provide accessibility and engagement, traditional methods offer structure and social interaction. By finding the right balance between the two, you can create a comprehensive language learning experience that caters to your child’s individual needs.

Ultimately, the goal is to foster a love for cultural exploration and language learning, encouraging your child to explore, practice, and communicate with confidence. Whether through apps, in-person settings, or cultural experiences, every step taken in this journey enriches their linguistic abilities and broadens their horizons. Happy language learning!

If you would like to receive more information on how to help your child learn a new language at home, sign up for our mailing list or check out our YouTube Channel!